5 Questions to Ask Before Writing a First Draft

This entry is part 3 of 3 in the series First Draft

First Draft

How to Write Your First Draft

First draft? Messy draft, vomit draft, or what?

5 Questions to Ask Before Writing a First Draft

There’s a particular kind of writer who sits down with a spark of an idea and starts writing immediately, fingers flying across the keyboard, the story pouring out of them like water from a burst pipe. These writers are rare, they’re magnificent, and they produce first drafts that are either brilliant or catastrophic, with very little in between. The rest of us – the vast majority, the ones who stare at the blank page for twenty minutes before typing a single word and then deleting it – need something different. We need a map. We need a starting point. We need to know which questions to ask before we commit to the long, beautiful, sometimes agonising journey of writing a first draft.

Because here’s the truth that nobody tells you when you’re starting out: the first draft isn’t where you figure out your story. That’s what planning is for. The first draft is where you tell the story you’ve already worked out – or at least worked out enough to know where you’re going. The planning doesn’t have to be exhaustive. It doesn’t have to fill a ring binder or a hundred-page spreadsheet. But it has to exist. And the best way to make it exist is to ask yourself five very specific questions before you write a single word of your manuscript.

These questions aren’t arbitrary. They’ve been refined by decades of writing teachers, best-selling novelists, and storytellers who’ve learned the hard way what happens when you skip them. They’re the questions that separate the first drafts that flow from the ones that stall at chapter three and never recover, only to surface some time later in a drawer, or folder on your computer, that you’ve totally forgotten about!

A little history

The practice of asking preparatory questions before writing has its roots in the ancient rhetorical traditions of Greece and Rome. Aristotle, in his Poetics, laid out the fundamental elements of storytelling – character, plot, thought, diction, and spectacle – not as a checklist for first drafts, but as a framework for understanding what makes a story work. His students would have been expected to consider each element before they began composing, not after. The idea that you should think about your story before you write it is, in a sense, two and a half thousand years old.

But the modern formulation of pre-draft questioning owes more to the twentieth century, and specifically to the screenwriting tradition. Hollywood, which has always been more interested in results than process, developed a culture of rigorous story development. Screenwriters were expected to write treatments, beat sheets, and outlines before they were allowed anywhere near a screenplay. The studio system didn’t have time for writers to “find the story” through drafts. They wanted to know the story before the draft was written. And so the practice of asking hard questions early – What’s the story about? Who’s the protagonist? What do they want? What’s stopping them? – became embedded in the DNA of professional storytelling.

Jeff Gerke, in his book The First 50 Pages, crystallised this approach for novelists. He argued that the opening pages of a novel are the most important, and that writers who skip the preparatory work produce opening pages that meander, confuse, and fail to hook the reader. His solution was brutally simple: answer a series of questions about your story before you start writing. Not vague questions. Specific ones. Questions that force you to confront the core of your narrative before you’ve committed 80,000 words to it.

K.M. Weiland, whose books on story structure are required reading for many writing courses, takes a similar approach. In Outlining Your Novel, she walks writers through a series of questions designed to uncover the story’s shape before the first draft begins. Her philosophy is that the first draft should be a discovery process, not a blank-page panic attack. The questions you ask before you write are the foundation that makes that discovery possible.

And then there’s the famously pantser-friendly approach of writers like Stephen King, who claims to start with a situation and see where it goes. Even King, though, asks questions before he writes. In On Writing, he describes how he starts with a “what if” question – what if a family were trapped in a hotel by a malevolent force? What if a young boy discovered he was a wizard? The question comes first. The story follows. Even the most instinctive, seat-of-the-pants writers are, in their own quiet way, asking the five questions before they begin.

The five questions

Here they are, in the order you should ask them. Not because the order is sacred – but because each question builds on the one before it, and the sequence makes the foundation solid.

Question 1: What is the story really about?

This is the question that separates stories that resonate from stories that merely happen. On the surface, it seems obvious – you know what your story is about, right? It’s about a detective solving a murder, or a woman falling in love, or a boy discovering he has magical powers. But that’s the plot, not the story. The plot is what happens. The story is what it means.

Every great story has a thematic core – a question about the human experience that the narrative explores and, ideally, answers. To Kill a Mockingbird isn’t just about a lawyer defending a wrongly accused man. It’s about moral courage and the loss of innocence. Pride and Prejudice isn’t just about a woman finding a husband. It’s about the danger of first impressions and the difficulty of seeing past your own assumptions. The plot is the vehicle. The theme is the destination.

When you sit down to write your first draft, you need to know what your story is really about. Not the surface-level description you’d give to a friend at a dinner party. The deeper truth. The thing that made you want to write this particular story in the first place. Because if you don’t know the destination, you’ll spend the entire draft wandering in circles, writing scenes that don’t build toward anything, creating characters who don’t grow, and producing a manuscript that feels, even to you, like it’s going somewhere but never quite arriving.

This doesn’t mean you need a thesis statement carved in stone. Themes can evolve as you write. But you need a starting point, a sense of what the story means to you, because that meaning will inform every decision you make – from the characters you create to the plot points you choose to the way you end the story.

Question 2: Who is the protagonist, and what do they want?

This question has two parts, and both are essential. The first part – who is the protagonist – seems simple, but it’s more nuanced than it appears. Your protagonist isn’t just the character who appears most often. They’re the character whose transformation the story follows. They’re the character who changes, or who fails to change, and that change (or lack of it) is what gives the story its emotional shape.

The second part – what do they want – is the engine of the plot. Every story needs a protagonist with a clear, specific, tangible desire. Not a vague wish (“she wants to be happy”) but a concrete goal (“she wants to find her birth mother before her wedding”). The desire creates the conflict. The conflict creates the story. Without a clear desire, the protagonist drifts, and a drifting protagonist produces a drifting story.

The history of this principle goes back to the earliest storytelling traditions. Aristotle argued that plot should follow character – that the things characters do should emerge naturally from who they are and what they want. This seems obvious, but you’d be surprised how many first drafts fail because the protagonist’s desire is unclear, inconsistent, or simply not interesting enough to sustain 80,000 words.

When you answer this question, be specific. Don’t say “she wants to find love.” Say “she wants to win back the person she pushed away because she was afraid of being vulnerable.” Don’t say “he wants to solve the mystery.” Say “he wants to prove that his brother was murdered, because everyone else believes it was an accident, and he can’t live with the uncertainty.” Specificity is what makes a protagonist compelling. Vagueness is what makes them forgettable.

Question 3: What stands in the way?

Every story needs an obstacle. Without it, there’s no conflict, and without conflict, there’s no story. The obstacle can be external – a villain, a disaster, a society that refuses to change – or internal – a fear, a flaw, a secret that the protagonist can’t face. Most stories have both, and the best stories weave them together so that the external obstacle reflects the internal one.

This question is closely linked to the second one. If the protagonist wants something, something has to stop them from getting it easily. If nothing stops them, the story is over in a paragraph. “She wanted to find her birth mother, and she found her. The end.” That’s not a story. That’s a Wikipedia entry.

The nature of the obstacle determines the shape of the story. A story where the obstacle is a powerful antagonist will feel different from a story where the obstacle is the protagonist’s own self-doubt. A story where the obstacle is external and physical (a war, a journey, a robbery) will have a different rhythm from a story where the obstacle is internal and emotional (grief, addiction, the fear of intimacy). Neither is better. But you need to know which kind of story you’re writing, because the obstacle is what generates the tension that keeps the reader turning pages.

When you answer this question, think about what makes the obstacle formidable. A weak obstacle produces a weak story. The obstacle should be something that the protagonist cannot overcome easily, something that forces them to grow, to change, to become someone different from who they were at the beginning. The obstacle is the crucible. The protagonist goes in as one person and comes out as another. That’s the story.

Question 4: What is the setting, and why does it matter?

Setting is not just backdrop. It’s not just a description of the weather and the architecture. Setting is a character in its own right, and the best stories use setting as an active force in the narrative rather than a passive stage on which the action happens.

Consider Wuthering Heights. The Yorkshire moors aren’t just a pretty landscape. They’re a reflection of Heathcliff and Catherine’s wild, untameable passion. The moors are the story, in a very real sense. Remove them, and the story collapses. Consider The Great Gatsby. The contrast between East Egg and West Egg isn’t just geography. It’s class, aspiration, and the lie at the heart of the American Dream. The setting is the theme, embodied in place.

When you answer this question, think about not just where the story takes place, but why it takes place there. Why couldn’t this story happen anywhere else? What does the setting give the story that nothing else could? If the answer is “nothing, the setting is arbitrary,” then you need to either choose a more meaningful setting or find a way to make the existing one matter.

Setting also includes time, and time matters enormously. A story set in 1920 has different rules, different expectations, different tensions than a story set in 2020. The period determines what your characters can do, what they can say, what they can aspire to, and what forces are working against them. Historical setting isn’t just costume and set dressing. It’s the social, political, and emotional landscape that shapes every decision your characters make.

Question 5: How does the story end?

This is the question that terrifies most writers, and it’s the question that matters most. Because if you don’t know how the story ends, you don’t know where you’re going. And if you don’t know where you’re going, you’ll spend the entire draft driving in circles, burning fuel, wearing down your tyres, and arriving nowhere.

I know, I know. You’ve heard the argument that some writers work best without knowing the ending. “I start with a situation and see where it goes,” they say. “The story tells me where it wants to end.” And sometimes that works. But here’s what those writers won’t tell you: they still have a sense of the ending, even if it’s vague. They have a feeling. A direction. A hunch about where the story is headed. They may not have the final sentence written in their head, but they know the emotional shape of the ending. They know whether it’s happy, tragic, ambiguous, or devastating. They know what the protagonist will become, even if they don’t know the exact moment of transformation.

The ending is the point of the story. Everything before it exists in service of that final moment. When you know the ending, every scene, every character, every plot point can be evaluated against it. Does this scene move me closer to the ending? Does this character’s arc resolve in a way that feels earned? Does this subplot connect to the ending, or does it drift off into nothing?

You don’t need to know every detail of the ending. But you need to know the emotional truth of it. What happens to the protagonist? What do they learn, or fail to learn? What changes, and what stays the same? When the reader closes the book, what should they feel? If you can answer those questions, you can write the draft. If you can’t, you’ll get lost in the middle, and the middle is where most novels go to die.

Five questions. Five answers. One sentence each. That’s the foundation of your first draft. Not an outline – a compass. You don’t need to know every turn. You need to know the direction.

Some guidelines

Now that we’ve covered the five questions, let’s talk about how to use the answers. Because knowing the questions is one thing. Using them effectively is another entirely. These guidelines will help you translate your preparatory thinking into a first draft that actually works, rather than a first draft that meanders vaguely in the direction of something that might, if you squint, resemble a story.

First, write your answers down. Don’t just think about them. Don’t hold them in your head like a secret you’re not quite ready to share. Write them on paper, in a document, on the back of a napkin if you have to. The act of writing forces clarity. Thoughts are slippery – they shift and change and evaporate the moment you try to pin them down. Words on a page are solid. When you write down “the protagonist wants to find her birth mother because she’s afraid she’ll be unloveable if she doesn’t know where she comes from,” that answer becomes a compass you can reference whenever you’re lost. And you will be lost. Every writer gets lost. The difference between a writer who finishes and a writer who doesn’t is that the finisher has a compass to follow back.

Second, revisit your answers as you write. The five questions aren’t a one-time exercise. They’re a living document. As you write the first draft, your understanding of the story will deepen and shift. The protagonist’s desire might evolve. The obstacle might change shape. The ending might surprise you – might become something you never anticipated, something better than what you had planned. That’s fine. That’s the creative process at its most exciting. But when it happens, go back to your answers and update them. Keep the compass calibrated. A story that drifts from its thematic core is a story that loses its way, and a story that loses its way loses its reader.

Third, don’t let the questions paralyse you. The goal of this exercise is to give you a foundation, not a prison. If you find yourself endlessly tweaking your answers, rewriting them, debating with yourself about whether the protagonist’s desire is “specific enough” or the obstacle is “formidable enough” or the ending is “ambiguous enough,” you’re procrastinating. You’re hiding behind the planning because the writing is scary. The answers don’t have to be perfect. They have to be good enough to start writing. You can refine them later. You will refine them later. That’s what revision is for. Right now, the job is to start.

Fourth, share your answers with someone. A writing partner, a critique partner, a trusted friend who reads widely and has opinions about stories. The act of explaining your story to another person forces you to articulate things you might have left vague. And the other person’s reaction – the confused look when you describe the protagonist’s motivation, the raised eyebrow when you explain the ending, the “wait, why would she do that?” when you describe a key plot point – is invaluable feedback. If they don’t understand the story, the reader won’t either. If they don’t care about the protagonist, the reader won’t either. The conversation doesn’t replace the writing. But it sharpens the thinking, and sharp thinking produces sharp stories.

Fifth, accept that the first draft will be imperfect. The five questions give you a roadmap, but the road itself will be bumpy. You’ll write scenes that don’t work. You’ll discover that the obstacle you planned isn’t as formidable as you thought. You’ll realise that the ending you envisioned doesn’t quite work, that the thematic truth you were aiming for feels heavy-handed or unclear. That’s normal. That’s what the second draft is for. The questions get you to the end of the first draft. The revision gets you to the end of the story. And the end of the story is the only place where perfection is even worth chasing.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, don’t skip the questions because you’re afraid of limiting yourself. This is the most common mistake, and it’s rooted in a misunderstanding of what creativity is. Many writers believe that planning kills creativity, that the best stories emerge from spontaneous, unplanned writing, that the muse will abandon you if you impose structure on her wild, free spirit. This is romantic, appealing, and almost entirely wrong. Creativity doesn’t come from chaos. It comes from constraint. The five questions don’t limit your creativity. They give it a direction. A river without banks is a swamp. A river with banks is a force of nature. The banks don’t constrain the water. They give it power.

Second, don’t answer the questions too vaguely. “The protagonist wants to be happy” is not an answer. It’s a placeholder for an answer. It’s the kind of answer you write when you don’t want to do the hard work of figuring out what you actually mean. “The protagonist wants to reconcile with her estranged daughter before her cancer diagnosis becomes terminal” is an answer. The specificity is what makes it useful. Vague answers produce vague stories. Specific answers produce stories that feel alive, urgent, and impossible to put down. Be specific. Be brave enough to be specific. The specificity is where the magic lives.

Third, don’t confuse plot with theme. “The story is about a murder” is a plot description. “The story is about the way grief can corrupt even the most loving relationship” is a thematic statement. Both matter, but they serve different purposes. The plot drives the action. The theme gives the action meaning. You need to know both, and you need to know which is which. If you only know the plot, you’ll write a story that’s full of events but empty of meaning. If you only know the theme, you’ll write a story that’s full of meaning but empty of events. Both are problems. Know both. Hold both. Let them inform each other.

Fourth, don’t ignore the ending. This is the question that most writers skip, and it’s the one that causes the most problems in the first draft. Without a clear ending, the middle becomes a swamp. Scenes pile up without building toward anything. Subplots branch off and never connect. The protagonist drifts from one situation to the next without a clear arc, like a leaf blown by the wind, going wherever the current takes them. Know the ending. Even if it changes. Even if it’s just a hunch. Even if it’s just a feeling about the emotional truth of the final moment. Know it, because it’s the light that guides you through the dark middle of the story.

Fifth, don’t spend so long answering the questions that you never start writing. The questions are a means, not an end. If you’ve been “planning” for six months and haven’t written a single word of the draft, you’re not planning. You’re hiding. The questions are supposed to make starting easier, not harder. If they’re making it harder, you’re overthinking them. Answer the questions in an afternoon. Then start writing. The questions will evolve as you write. You can refine them later. But you can’t refine something that doesn’t exist. Start. Now. Today. Not tomorrow. Not next week. Today.

Key takeaways

First, the five questions – what is the story about, who is the protagonist and what do they want, what stands in the way, why does the setting matter, and how does it end – are the foundation of every successful first draft. They’re not optional. They’re not just for planners. Every story, whether it’s outlined in detail or discovered through writing, needs answers to these questions. The answers might be vague at first. They might change as you write. But they have to exist, because without them, you’re not writing a story. You’re typing.

Second, specificity is the writer’s best friend. Vague answers produce vague stories. When you can articulate exactly what your protagonist wants, exactly what stands in the way, and exactly how the story ends, you have the tools to write a first draft that feels focused, purposeful, and alive. Specificity is what separates a story that resonates from a story that merely happens. Be specific. Be brave. Be precise. The magic lives in the details.

Third, the questions are a living document. They’re not a contract carved in stone. They’re a compass that guides you through the wilderness of the first draft. As you write, your understanding of the story will deepen, and your answers should deepen with it. Revisit them. Update them. Let them evolve as the story evolves. A story that grows is a story that lives.

Fourth, write your answers down. Don’t hold them in your head. Write them on paper, in a document, on the wall of your study, wherever you can see them. The act of writing forces clarity, and clarity is what you need when you’re 40,000 words into a draft and can’t remember why you started writing this particular story. The answers are your anchor. Hold onto them.

Fifth, accept imperfection. The questions get you to the end of the first draft. They don’t get you to perfection. That’s what revision is for. The first draft’s job is to exist. The questions make it a good existence. The revision makes it a great one. Don’t aim for perfect on the first pass. Aim for finished. Perfect can wait. Finished can’t.

Wrapping up

Writing a first draft is one of the most daunting tasks a human being can undertake. You’re taking something that doesn’t exist – a story, a world, a collection of characters who live only in your imagination – and making it real. You’re translating the invisible into the visible, the private into the shared, the imagined into the written. It’s terrifying and exhilarating in equal measure, and it’s one of the most deeply human things you can do.

The five questions we’ve discussed aren’t magic. They won’t make the writing easy. They won’t eliminate the doubt, the fear, the moments when you’re convinced that you’re wasting your time and everyone would be better off if you just went back to your day job and left the novel-writing to the professionals. But the questions will give you a foundation. A starting point. A reason to keep going when the middle gets murky and the end feels unreachable. They’ll give you something to hold onto when the story feels like it’s slipping through your fingers like water.

Because here’s the thing about first drafts: they’re acts of faith. You’re writing something that no-one has asked for, no-one is waiting for, and no-one will see until you decide it’s ready. You’re spending months working on something that might be brilliant or might be garbage, and you won’t know which until it’s finished. That takes courage. And courage, like writing, is a practice. You don’t have it once and keep it forever. You have to find it again every time you sit down at your desk, every time you face the blank page, every time you type the first sentence of a new chapter and wonder whether it’s any good.

The five questions don’t eliminate the need for courage. But they give you something to be courageous about. They give your story a shape, a direction, a purpose. They turn the terrifying blank page into a manageable set of tasks. They transform “write a novel” into “explore what happens when this person wants this thing and can’t get it, and how that changes them.” And that transformation – from the overwhelming to the manageable – is what makes the questions so powerful.

So ask the questions. Write the answers. And then write the draft. Because somewhere inside you, there’s a story that only you can tell. And it’s been waiting long enough. It’s been patient. It’s been sitting in the dark, hoping you’d find your way to it. The five questions are the flashlight. The first draft is the path. The story is the destination. And the journey, however terrifying, is worth every word.

And that’s the final truth. The questions are the work. They’re the part of the process that nobody sees, the foundation that holds the whole structure up, the invisible architecture that makes the visible story possible. The amateur waits for the perfect idea, the perfect moment, the perfect mood. The professional asks the right questions and starts writing. Your first draft is waiting. It’s been waiting. Ask the questions. Write the answers. Begin. Today. Right now. The story is ready. Are you?